In the animated Disney movie Tangled, a young woman named Rapunzel
wants only one thing for her birthday: to leave her tower and see the floating
lanterns that she has been gazing at since as long as she can remember. Little
does she know that those lanterns are actually for her- a plea to find the long
lost princess, a victim of kidnapping as an infant. The tower she lives in is her
kidnapper’s home, and she is not allowed to leave. This girl is the protagonist
of the movie. When I scored the movie against the representation test, it was
clear the film did not do so well. Scoring a C, Tangled does not represent minorities, LGBT people, people with
disabilities, or men well nor accurately.
Overall, the diversity of the film
is less than acceptable. Every single one of the characters is white. (This
might have a bit to do with the setting of the film in Germany, but there is
still no excuse). There are no characters represented from a minority ethnic
group, race, or culture. The lead male is handsome, strong, and a criminal, all
of which are characteristics we see in films all the time.
However, the strong suit of the
film is the representation and portrayal of women. Rapunzel, the main character
and protagonist, is a seventeen year old girl whose eighteenth birthday is
coming up in a few days. She has goals and dreams that are related to more than
just a man. They have significant value to her. Not surprisingly, there is indeed
a side plot that does have her fall into the arms of the main male character,
Flynn Rider. Although this is extremely typical of a woman in a movie to do, I
still give credit to the film for accurately representing women as a whole.
Supporting characters include Rapunzel’s
mother, several tough men at a bar, and two criminals trying to catch Flynn
Rider. The mother is well represented, given that she is a strong female
character with intentions other than finding a man to love. Unfortunately, the
men in the bar come across as tough, scary, and even threatening. The two men on
the hunt for Flynn Rider are muscular thieves with the intent to kill if need
be. The children’s film seems to glorify violence, especially in regards to the
men, which gives an inaccurate representation of men in general.
In my personal opinion, the representation test does not measure the quality of a movie or whether or not it is necessarily “good,” but it does accurately measure the diversity of the characters in the film. The test considers women, men, race, culture, ethnicity, the LGBT community, people with disabilities, and even looks behind the scenes for misrepresentation of the society as a whole. As previously stated, the setting of the film might have given reasons to cast only white characters, as it takes place in Germany. Since it was so popular in the United States, however, one could argue that there is underrepresentation. Even though Tangled is one of my favorite movies, I can agree with the results of the representation test and say that the film does not do a good job of keeping the characters well represented in any way.
In my personal opinion, the representation test does not measure the quality of a movie or whether or not it is necessarily “good,” but it does accurately measure the diversity of the characters in the film. The test considers women, men, race, culture, ethnicity, the LGBT community, people with disabilities, and even looks behind the scenes for misrepresentation of the society as a whole. As previously stated, the setting of the film might have given reasons to cast only white characters, as it takes place in Germany. Since it was so popular in the United States, however, one could argue that there is underrepresentation. Even though Tangled is one of my favorite movies, I can agree with the results of the representation test and say that the film does not do a good job of keeping the characters well represented in any way.
No comments:
Post a Comment